How Grateful Do You Have to Be?

Perhaps you have started a sentence like this:

I know I’m lucky to be here, but...

Or:

I’m really grateful for the opportunities Australia has given me, but...

And only once you have laid a layer of gratitude do you say what actually happened. The job where your overseas experience suddenly seemed to count for less. The migration process that left you exhausted. The loneliness. The racism. The feeling that you had to prove yourself all over again.

You put the gratitude first, a disclaimer, an assurance that you will not rock the boat. 

I’ve not yet been able to find an answer to this question: How grateful do you have to be before you are allowed to tell the truth about what migration cost you?

Really. How much gratitude is enough?

How many years do you have to work? How much tax do you have to pay? How successful do you need to become? How many times do you need to say that Australia has given you opportunities before you are allowed to say that something was unfair, dehumanising or simply much harder than you expected?

I’ve realised there is no answer because there is no measurement.

Perhaps that is because this was never really about how grateful you are. Perhaps the point was never for you to become grateful enough.

Perhaps the point was for you to remain indebted.

As though being allowed to build a life here created a debt that could never quite be repaid. You work, contribute, pay taxes, adapt, learn unfamiliar systems and leave people, places and parts of your life behind. You absorb the cost of starting again.

And still, somewhere underneath it all, there can be this expectation that you should continue proving that the opportunity to be here was worth the sacrifice, and that you are worthy of the opportunity you were given.

But what would repayment even look like? More sacrifice? More adapting? Less criticism? More silence?

If the debt can never be repaid, gratitude stops being simply an emotion.

It becomes a way of keeping you in your place.

You Learn the Rule Without Anyone Saying It

Nobody needs to sit you down and explain that you should be grateful. You learn it by watching what happens when a migrant criticises Australia.

“If you don’t like it, leave.”

You notice how quickly a conversation about racism can become a conversation about how fortunate you are to live here. You notice which migration stories are celebrated and which ones make people uncomfortable.

You begin to understand what kind of migrant is easiest to welcome: grateful, hardworking, successful, adaptable and resilient.

You can talk about hardship, but preferably with an uplifting ending. You struggled, but you overcame. Your qualifications were not recognised, but you worked your way back up. You were lonely, but eventually you found your people.

The story is easier to hear when it reassures everyone that the system basically works.

The harder story is that sometimes you did everything asked of you and the system still failed you. Sometimes you were treated unfairly. Sometimes migration gave you opportunities while also costing you enormously.

Gratitude and anger live side by side in the same body.

Never Become Too Much

Perhaps that is the real rule.

Don’t become too angry, too critical, too demanding, too foreign, too unwilling to assimilate or too confident about the value of the experience you brought with you.

You can bring your culture, as long as it remains comfortable. Food, festivals, clothes and music are easy to celebrate.

But what happens when you bring your criticism too?

What happens when you say, I don’t only want to be included in this system. I want to be able to question it.

What happens when you stop believing that belonging should depend on how comfortable you can make everyone else with your presence?

That is a different kind of participation, and perhaps a more honest one.

The Problem Is Not Always Inside You

This is where the system becomes incredibly effective.

If your overseas experience is repeatedly discounted and you conclude, I need to prove myself harder, nobody has to question how international experience is valued.

If someone struggles to understand your accent and you conclude, I need to sound less like myself, nobody has to ask whether listening across accents is also a communication skill.

If you experience racism and immediately wonder, Am I being too sensitive?, nobody else has to examine what happened.

If you feel excluded and decide, I need to integrate better, the community does not have to ask what it is doing to create belonging.

The dominant culture gets to remain the standard. Its way of speaking, working and communicating is treated as normal. You become the variation, and the variation is expected to adapt.

Eventually, nobody needs to keep telling you to change because you have learnt to tell yourself.

What Goes Unsaid Is Still Present

In narrative therapy there is an idea called the absent but implicit.

Sometimes what is not being said tells you a great deal about what is present.

If you feel guilty for criticising something, what expectation is sitting behind that guilt? If you need to establish your gratitude before talking about racism, what are you afraid your criticism will mean about you? If asking for more makes you feel demanding, what have you learnt about how much you are allowed to need?

These narratives do not disappear because nobody says them aloud.

Sometimes silence is exactly how they survive. The rule remains invisible, but you still feel its consequences.

Your Anger Holds Wisdom

Perhaps you have spent a lot of time trying to get rid of anger, resentment, grief or disappointment because you worry those feelings make you ungrateful.

I am interested in a different question: What do those feelings know?

What does your anger know about how you believe people deserve to be treated? What does your disappointment tell you about what you hoped Australia would be? What does your frustration know about fairness?

Maybe your anger is not evidence that you have failed to appreciate your life here. Maybe it is telling you that something you value has been violated: respect, fairness, dignity, equality or belonging.

Maybe the uncomfortable feeling is not the problem.

Maybe it is carrying information.

You can love your life in Australia. You can feel fortunate to be here. You can appreciate the opportunities, safety, community or freedom you have found.

None of that has to disappear.

And gratitude should not require silence. It should not cancel anger or grief, and it should not turn every disappointment into your personal failure.

People born in Australia criticise Australia every day. They complain about housing, healthcare, politics, transport, taxes and workplaces. Nobody asks them to prove their gratitude before they speak.

Why should your belonging come with different conditions?

Perhaps criticism is not evidence that you do not belong.

Perhaps it is one of the ways you participate.

I Am Not Interested in Keeping Quiet

There are things about migration that are rarely spoken about publicly, not because you don’t know them, but because you know them intimately.

Sometimes what you need is not another person explaining migration to you. You need someone willing to say the thing you already know. To put language around what has been sitting there unnamed. To ask who benefits from the story you have been using to judge yourself, and whether the problem you have placed inside yourself ever belonged there in the first place.

I am increasingly unwilling to leave these things unsaid simply because silence makes the system more comfortable.

I don’t believe counselling should help you become more compliant with a story that is hurting you. I am more interested in helping you examine it. Where did it come from? Who benefits when you believe it? What does it ask you to silence? What have you already been doing to resist it?

And who might you become if you stopped organising your life around never being “too much”?

Perhaps the question was never:

Am I grateful enough to say this?

Perhaps the question is:

Why was I taught that gratitude was required before my experience could be believed?

You probably already know why some of these things go unsaid.

I do too.

Safety matters. If you want to explore your full experience in a space that doesn’t require you to only show parts of yourself, my door is open. Send me a DM or book in a time to chat here: https://calendar.app.google/RRTKQoYmNdYexkye7




Next
Next

The Part of Migration No One Sees